China beam-down CSP pioneer predicts 30% cost reduction
The developer of the world's first commercial beam-down CSP plant predicts a four-fold hike in thermal efficiency for a larger 200 MW plant.
As CSP developers seek new ways to cut costs, a new 50 MW beam-down tower plant in China will provide valuable insights into an emerging CSP technology.
Developed by BCP Solar Technology (known in China as Xinchen Solar), the RMB 1.8 billion ($255 million) Yumen Xinneng plant will include 15 beam-down tower modules and a 9-hour molten salt storage system. China Sinogy Electric Engineering Co. a subsidiary of Thvow, is the engineering procurement construction (EPC) supplier.
The first module at Yumen Xinneng has passed commissioning tests and installation work on modules two and three are “almost completed,” Yuda Chen, General Manager of BCP, told New Energy Update.
Located 5km from Yumen City in Gansu province, Yumen Xinneng is the only project in China's 1.35 GW CSP Commercial Demonstration Pilot program to use beam-down technology. China awarded 20 projects in the program at a feed-in tariff price of RMB 1.15/kWh ($170/MWh).
Global CSP cost, auction price trends
Source: International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), January 2018.
The BCP design replaces the elevated receiver used in conventional CSP tower plants with a secondary 'hyperboloidal' reflector, which bounces solar energy from heliostats to a ground-based receiver.
The Yumen Xinneng plant follows a 300 kW pilot plant built by BCP in 2015 with co-developer Shanghai Parasol. Despite limited deployment, the installed unit cost of the Yumen Xinneng plant is below RMB 7/kWh/year, competitive against other conventional plants in the pilot demonstration round, Chen said.
“The CAPEX of the receiver system is lower than in conventional systems, but the numbers required, and unit price of the beam-down tower offset this," he said.
BCP predicts modular scaling gains and new design features will slice the cost for larger projects. The group is currently developing a second-generation module which will increase the rated thermal power four-fold, providing 200 MW of capacity from 14 modules, Chen said
“At this scale the cost will decrease by 30% compared to levels at Yumen Xinneng,” he said.
The modular BCP design uses a fan-shaped layout of heliostats and lower towers than conventional tower plants, ensuring high solar utilization rates, Chen said.
The design uses a 3D volumetric receiver, rather than the tubular receiver used on conventional towers, which minimizes optical and thermal losses and offers high-temperature capabilities.
3D designs can reduce radiation losses compared with current 2D options as the maximum temperature is reached inside the volumetric absorber structure, reducing front surface losses.
“The thermal efficiency of the volumetric receiver can reach 90.5% at nominal load, and 88% annual average efficiency, compared to less than 60% levels for conventional external receivers at full load,” Chen said.
In July, the first module at the Yumen Xinneng plant heated the molten salt heat transfer medium to 570 degrees C. This compares to an average temperature of around 485° C for today's operational tower plants, according to data from the CSP Global Tracker.
A number of research groups are raising the temperature limits of CSP plants to increase system efficiency.
A U.S. research team is currently developing a 3D volumetric receiver that operates at over 720°C and has a thermal efficiency rate above 92%.
The team, led by Sameer Rao, an Assistant Professor in Mechanical Engineering at the University of Utah, was recently awarded funding from the Department of Energy to validate the design and experiment at lab-scale.
Other groups are testing alternative heat transfer mediums in new high-temperature designs. In one example, the German Aerospace Centre (DLR) is developing a centrifugal CSP receiver which has already achieved particle temperatures of 965°C at the receiver outlet.
The BSP volumetric receiver uses an innovative two-tank direct-heated molten salt system which eliminates the risk of molten salt freezing and ensures operational stability, Chen said.
The design features a double-layer molten salt storage tank that offers higher thermal inertia than single-layer units.
The receiver cover can be closed quickly during cloud cover to maintain the heat of the molten salt, enabling the receiver to restart within a few minutes of skies clearing, Chen said.
This makes the design particular suitable for areas subject to frequent cloud cover, such as the north-west of China, he said.
BCP believes its modular beam-down concept offers scaling advantages during manufacturing, construction and operations.
Modular plant developers can use factory line efficiencies and advanced manufacturing technologies to gain economies of series.
The BCP receiver can be manufactured using standard stainless steel products, unlike conventional tower receivers which require specialized materials, Chen noted.
Minimizing the cost of more specialized components, such as the special hyperboloidal reflectors used in the receiver chain, could prove more of a challenge. Critics of beam-down designs have questioned the cost of manufacturing these items.
BCP will continue to optimize the reflector area and curvature and maximize mirror reflectivity using new materials, Chen said.
Modular designs also allow synchronized construction and faster returns on investments, as the first modules can be brought online to generate revenues while others are built. BCP estimates a 24-month construction period for a 200 MW plant.
China Sinogy won the EPC contract for Yumen Xinneng based on a construction duration of 19 months, which proved too ambitious for the first commercial-scale project. The project is now 29 months into construction, but it is advancing quicker than many other projects in China's pilot program.
To-date, only two CSP tower projects under the program have been connected to the grid. The 50 MW Supcon Delingha plant was built in 26 months and the 100 MW Shouhang Dunhuang plant was completed in 37 months, data from the CSP Global Tracker shows.
The modular layout of small CSP towers also opens up new siting opportunities on sites with less favorable local weather conditions or uneven topology.
Smaller towers are subject to less environmental permitting restrictions and can be more protected from wind and sand erosion or heat loss during colder months.
Modular plants can also offer greater revenue reliability, as faults in individual modules can be repaired while other units remain operational.
The BCP design could also be adapted to create much larger plants that could serve multiple power and heat applications, Chen said.
“By distributing heat collection, transportation and centralized heat storage we could see scales push 600 MW [total energy]," he said.
By Kerry Chamberlain